Chewy sent us this cat toy at no charge in exchange for our cats’ review.

These cats crack me up. You think you know them, and they do this:

Small enough to be carried around the house? YES (The dimensions are 4.5 inches in length, 3.5 inches in width, and 1 inch in height)
Crinkle sounds? YES
Catnip? YES

Win!Win!Win?

NOPE.

There are at least four cats on Chewy that love this thing. It’s been unloved in my dining/living room area for weeks. I even put catnip on another toy and this one, and left them both out (to make sure our catnip is still good). The boys played with the other toy.
This crinkly shimmer glimmer fish is still in the floor.

On the plus side, they got a new cardboard box from Chewy.
Check out the Shimmer Glimmer Fish Cat Toy (colors vary)

All orders $49+ get free, fast shipping